Bad Teacher, Good Teacher

Published on September 23, 2004 By KarmaGirl In Home & Family

My daughter is one of the youngest in her grade. She is in 1st grade and won't be 6 until the end of October. Last year, during Kindergarten round up, the Principal strongly suggested that we put her in early 5's instead of kindergarten. I refused because she had already been in Parents as Teachers, 3 year-old preschool and 4 year-old preschool (which was taught at the school by one of the Kindergarten teachers). The teacher from 4 year-old preschool said that she was more than ready to go to school the next year.

Well, being new to the area, I had no idea about the teachers. My daughter was placed in the least favorite teacher's classroom. the only feedback I really got from my daughter was that he teacher "yells a lot" (not a good sign). This teacher basically told me from day one, without even testing my child, that she would have to be held back. The last conference of the year, she sent me a note saying that we needed to meet to "talk about next year", so I made the meeting time. The day before this meeting, the teacher called and said that she finally tested my daughter, and she was shocked because she tested way higher than she expected. I felt like saying "just think how well she would have done if you wouldn't have written her off in the beginning"?

So, now she is in first grade. We went to orientation and she is the youngest and smallest child in her class. The little boys love her (great). Anyway, her teacher said that my daughter is "quiet" (wish that were true at home) and they were going to test her and see what she could do. At first I thought "great, another year of this". But, to my pleasant surprise, I was sent home a report on her "literature" skills. She had scored a perfect 100%. The next week I received a letter asking permission to enter her in their Literature program, which is for the kids who scored the best. Yay! And, my daughter is so excited because she gets *more* work than the other kids (guess she hasn't figured that one out yet) and she gets different books and goes to the library more.

It makes me happy that they didn't write her off this year. My daughter has always loved stories and books and has been trying so hard to learn how to read and spell. She has memorized about 50+ books that she has, and has a membership to our city library. Hopefully this one step will keep her ahead in the game and will keep future teachers from letting her fall in the gaps.

Comments

Texas Wahine

on Sep 23, 2004

That's great, Karma. It's so sad when you get a teacher who makes his/her mind up about a child right away before he/she has the chance to observe the child's ability and understand what makes the child tick. Congrats to your daughter on the Literature program, and on ending up with the "good" teacher as well. It really does make such a difference in their education when they have someone who is interested in helping them reach their full potential rather than simply keeping them quiet and busy.

Sally jacobs

on Sep 23, 2004

Wow your daughter has done good! I remember loving books at school, and thinking I was really good getting more work, hehe, I eventually figured that one out, but enjoy it while it lasts. Teachers have alot of work, but that doesn't mean they shouldn't give all kids a fair chance, at least they realised your daughter has talent, took them long enough huh!

qrush

on Sep 23, 2004

KG, I started school a year early too, and I certainly don't regret the decision that my parents made. Yes, I had to wait a bit to get my driving permit, but other than that, it's only benefited me. I wish you a big good luck, and I hope she keeps those awesome grades up.

qrush

on Sep 23, 2004

citahellion

on Sep 23, 2004

I felt like saying "just think how well she would have done if you wouldn't have written her off in the beginning"?

I wish you had said that! A teacher who does that needs a good swift boot to the head to shake out bad preconceptions.

Welcome Guest! Please take the time to register with us.
There are many great features available to you once you register, including:

Richer content, access to many features that are disabled for guests like commenting on the forums.
Access to a great community, with a massive database of many, many areas of interest.
Access to contests & subscription offers like exclusive emails.
It's simple, and FREE!